NNE NEWS: Is European Commission Caution on Tobacco Regulation Based on Science?
In early February, during a parliamentary Subcommittee on Tax Matters hearing, Hoekstra was asked about the European Commission’s plans to review the TED. He responded by saying, “smoking kills, vaping kills”. Referring specifically to vaping products, he added: “We need to do more. This is highly addictive and deliberately structured to be addictive. The sector is mercilessly lobbying for more room and knows very well that this approach only continues the problem.”
The World Vapers’ Alliance (WVA) strongly condemned Hoekstra’s remarks, arguing that his claim that vaping “kills like ordinary cigarettes” is false and misleading. The WVA criticised Hoekstra’s justification for higher taxes on vapes and flavours, calling it an example of fear-based policy-making rather than fact-driven regulation.
During the hearing, Hoekstra also suggested that flavoured e-cigarettes “seduce” young people and create a “false sense of security”. He further asserted the scientifically inaccurate claim that vaping is as deadly as smoking.
Alberto Gómez Hernández, policy manager at the WVA, denounced Hoekstra’s statements as “dangerous and irresponsible”.
He said: “The science is clear: vaping is at least 95% less harmful than smoking and remains the most effective tool to help smokers quit. Equating vaping with smoking is not only misleading but also discourages smokers from switching to a far less harmful alternative.”
According to the latest Eurobarometer survey, a significant majority of adult vapers prefer non-tobacco flavours, with fruit flavours being particularly popular.
“Flavours are not a marketing ploy to attract youth; they are a vital tool for adult smokers looking to switch to safer alternatives,” said Gómez Hernández. “Higher taxes on flavoured vapes would make it significantly harder for vapers to stay away from combustible tobacco, potentially driving up smoking rates.
“If the EU is serious about reducing smoking rates, it must embrace harm-reduction strategies that include vaping. Spreading misinformation and imposing prohibitive taxes will only serve to protect the cigarette industry at the expense of public health.”
Debate over tobacco and vaping rages on, but major regulatory shifts likely won’t happen before there are further reviews in the coming years. Still, policies remain fluid, and change is always on the table.
Tobacco Intelligence (www.tobaccointelligence.com) provides impartial, independent and premium market and regulatory analysis, legal tracking, and quantitative data for the global tobacco and nicotine-alternatives sector.
We provide our clients with the tools to navigate this fast-moving sector, tailor their business strategy, optimise resources and make informed decisions. In addition, we offer customised research and consultancy support.
